Is Xavier House for sale? by Dino Crescini, BS, MBA

Located along Herran Street in Sta. Ana Manila, Xavier House is a historic property owned by the Jesuit Province in the Philippines. It may even be considered as an extension of Ateneo de Manila University. I remember some closed retreats I attended there when I was a young student.

 

The house was built shortly after WWII and has indeed earned its place in Philippine history. For many years, it has also been the home of Rev. Fr. James Reuter, SJ, one of the oldest living Jesuit in the Philippines who will soon be turning 93.

 

Many of his former students will remember him as the talented director of many stage plays presented by the Ateneo. Some of these are Gilbert & Sullivan’s The Mikado, Christopher Fry’s The Lady’s not for Burning, and Robert Louis Stevenson’s Treasure Island.

 

He taught many of us how to sing in four voices – bass, tenor, baritone, alto and even young grade school students capable of reaching high notes how to sing soprano. Indeed, he is the backbone of the Ateneo de Manila University Glee Club.

 

Now, the place that he called home for more than 40 years has been offered up for sale by the Jesuit Province, presumably because of financial difficulties. Apparently, the rising costs of medical care for senior and infirm Jesuits have taken a toll on Jesuit resources. Fr. Reuter has been offered by his superiors to move to the Ateneo campus in Loyola Heights, Quezon City.

 

Broadcast location of Radio Bandido

 

During the People Power Revolution in 1986, the Xavier House became the secret broadcast location of Radio Bandido’s June Keighley who monitored developments in EDSA. She was of course, under the direction of Fr. Reuter who was the frontrunner of Radio Veritas.

 

Conversion into a shopping mall

 

There are conflicting stories about the sale of Xavier House. A report made by the Philippine Daily Inquirer stated that the sale has been consummated with SM Group as 

the buyer. If true, SM will no doubt be demolishing Xavier House to give way to another shopping mall.

 

However, Fr. Jose Magadia, S.J. who is head of the Jesuit Province in the Philippines said that the news about the sale is not true. He added that the Province has had no contact with the SM Group.

 

But what can an old priest do? He has a vow of obedience and must comply with orders given by his superiors.

 

Latest clarification from Fr. Magadia, S.J.

 

In its issue of 31 March 2009, the Philippine Daily Inquirer (PDI) ran a front page article on the ‘sale’ of Xavier House that demands some clarifications, not only because of its misstatements of fact but also on account of the innuendoes and implications it fosters.

 

1. The article falsely claims that a done deal has been made between the Philippine Province of the Society of Jesus and the SM Group for the purchase of the Xavier House property. The Provincial and Province Treasurer are quoted as denying this; but a source from the SM Group (conveniently left unnamed) is produced to state the contrary. In no uncertain terms the article adopts the latter as the correct version. This is not true. The Province has had no contact with the SM Group, has not even gotten to the point of putting the Xavier House property up for sale.

 

2. The PDI article also tends to misrepresent the whole issue as if it were nothing more than a money-making scheme. It brushes aside the reality that the Province is in real financial straits, exacerbated by the ongoing world financial crisis. The rising costs of medical care for our senior and infirm Jesuits and formation for our younger men have taken a toll on province resources. These resources are dedicated to almost a third of Philippine Jesuits who are in formation, and an even bigger group of some 110 who are over 70 years of age, 61 of whom are 80 and above. Along with this, the Province also has to support other works that are not self-sufficient. It is unfortunate that people do not realize that the Province is not Ateneo de Manila or Xavier School, and that funds do not come out of one big pot that is commonly shared.

 

3. Fr. James Reuter, with whom I spoke this morning, is very much dismayed at and disturbed by the PDI article. He lamented the distortions it presented and the picture of him and of the Jesuits that the article unfairly painted. Father Reuter continues to affirm that the Society of Jesus he entered almost seventy-five years ago has always cared for him and will continue to do so to the end. He well knows that despite all difficulties, the Philippine Province remains committed to make sure that all our Jesuits in our different communities are provided for and attended to.

 

JOSE C. J. MAGADIA, S.J.

Provincial

Updated: 2009-05-03 — 06:59:41